After studying the lesson, here are my two cents worth:
Teacher roles (score : 7)
The teacher stimulates students’ interest by making them role-play as different characters like the Secret Agents and the World Bank Budget Committee members. The lesson was designed in such a way that that teacher doesn’t provide the students with answers or limitations to the content and students were responsible for exploring information of the topic via sources (eg textbook, internet or online forum). The teacher served the class as an instruction leader.
The teacher also managed the lesson by setting and keeping the curricular goals. She monitored the students’ time management to ensure that the curriculum was covered. However, there were no enough time allocated for the students to take down notes and categorise their learnings in the form of mindmaps thus resulting in certain students unable to fully capture and understand the content.
Lastly, the teacher also monitored students’ discussions and participated in the forum discussion. She included intervention, facilitation and skillful questioning to restate students’ understandings. The forum discussion also allowed conversation and collaboration between students.
Student Roles (score : 8 )
The students were the main character of the classroom. They were responsible of finding information via prior knowledge from what they had read or seen from television programmes or by doing individual research over internet, online journals, textbooks and books. They assimilated the information that fits into their lesson and drew a conclusion for the different perspectives they gathered from their research. In a way, this helps them develop analytical skills and experience hands-on learning journey which helps them connect better with the curriculum.
On top of that, students were also in charge of taking down notes for their own learning and creating better understanding of the curriculum using mindmapping tool. Students who were presenting also made use of Microsoft Powerpoint to put their presentations together for the other students. These IT tools encourage students to improve on their oral communication and also prepare them for future workforce demand. However, proper guidance on usage of IT tools were not given to the students, thus resulting in some students unable to catch up and making learning ineffective.
Informal conversations like online forum were also created for the students to talk about the topic presented. Students may ask questions or feedback on the presentations. The presenters may also circulate among their classmates for discussions or to clarify doubts and provide solutions to their classmates’ problems. Social interaction enhances learning as every individual gained knowledge and understanding from discussions, conversations and explanations.
By and large, students were less reliable on their teacher as they were independent and initiative for knowledge creation. As they gathered their information via real-world resources, their learnings expand beyond the textbook. Technology also allows students to manipulate information which aids in accelerating understanding and stimulating higher-order thinking skills.
Curriculum Characteristics (score : 7)
The lesson was created in such a way where students take responsibilities in their own learning and were allowed to construct meaning and understanding for themselves. Students developed analytical and decision making skills as they compared the different perspectives they gathered from various resources and analysing them before concluding and synthesizing the data into a refined report using digital resources.
When asked to use technology in their learning, students were unable to tap the full potential of the technology tools provided despite being technically competent due to the lack of cognitive guidance during the first lesson. However, with the teacher’s modelling and guidance during the second lesson, they were able to capitalise the full potential of the teachnology tools to enhance their learning thus leveling their understanding on the topic.
Students were also engaged in online forum for questioning, clarifications and sharing of ideas. By discussing, explaining and listening, students learnt from the interactions exchanged, which helped them develop understanding and allowed the flow of ideas.
Learning Goals (score : 8 )
The students were tasked to develop their own understanding based on prior knowledge, experience and gaining new knowledge from various resources like the internet, journals and textbooks. Students were able to work independently as they relied lesser on their teacher and became more initiative in knowledge creation. In a way, they were also decision makers as they compared and contrasted the different perspective research found on various sources and formed their own understanding and conclusion.
By presenting their research via powerpoint and taking down notes via mindmapping tools, the students are now trained to meet demands of the working force.
Students were also encouraged to discuss and interact over online forum in order to learn more through discussions, explanations, exchanging of ideas, feedbacks and listening. The informal interaction allowed flow of ideas which challenged students to use higher degree of thinking skills thus allowing them to analyse, create or synthesis ideas which in turn elevated the students’ level of understand to a higher level.
Types of Activities (score : 6)
The types of activities involved are firstly group project with hands on exploration for content. Students with the role as Secret Agent presented their topics via Powerpoint Presentation and students who were in the World Bank Budget Committee took down notes using mindmapping tools. Next, students were encouraged to interact in the online forum and at the end of the lesson, they were asked to vote in an online poll and also to indicate one thing they had learnt from the lesson.
Of all the activities listed, only the online polling and to indicate one thing they have learnt from the lesson were compulsory for all students to participate in. Some students may be neglected in other activities which may result in unconducive learning to take place.
Assessment Strategies (score : 6)
Students were asked to vote for either one of the projects through online polling. They were able to make a decision on which issue they were supporting and they were required to indicate one thing they learnt under the topic. The teacher provided a decision-making template for the students to rank the issue but due to lack of proper guidance, students did not manage to rank correctly until the second lesson, where proper instructions were given to them by the teacher.
There was no written test given and the only things that could be used to assess the student’s understand of the topics were the online forum, online polling, the presentation and the mindmap done by them. I feel that based on the given choices, it was not enough to confirm that all students fully understand the topics. Therefore, a written test is still needed to test and confirm that student fully understand the topics.
Use of ICT (score : 6)
Technology indeed enrich, extend and facilitate learning. Independent learning through sources like internet, online journals or online forum gives students the chance of having complete control over the topic and enables students to build on their own understanding.
Mindmapping and Powerpoint Presentations serve as excellent visual organiser for students to display their projects and conveying their understands and interpretation. Online forum also encouraged discussions, clarifications and flow of ideas when different perspections were expressed.
Students were asked to vote for the project they support via online poll. This served as a feedback for the presenters on how convincing they were. Students were also asked to indicate one thing they learnt in the lesson to let the teacher keep track of their understand of the lesson.
However, there are many other IT tools like simulations, multimedia and hypermedia which are not used by the students. These IT tools require proper guidance and training thus it will be useful if experts are engaged to deliver the IT skills to the students.
All in all, I feel that the lesson was quite well planned except that more time should be allocated for students to process the mind maps and also for discussions and clarifications. I feel that if more time is allocated to these 3 areas, students will be able to learn and understand the topics better.